dangerousmeta!, the original new mexican miscellany, offering eclectic linkage since 1999.

Wired: The new Sherlock Holmes movie, with a reimagined Sherlock.

Screen: Robert Downey Jr.’s Sherlock — Faithful or Flawed? “But Guy Ritchie, who directed the film, says making the sleuth more of a stud is staying true to Sir Arthur Conan Doyle’s original stories.” If you’ve ever read any of the stories, you’ll know that Robert Downey Jr. is just a wrong choice (in spite of his massive acting cred).  He is not ‘rather over six feet’, he is not so ‘excessively lean he seems taller’, nor does he have a ‘thin, hawklike nose’ (to use Conan Doyle’s own descriptions).  Jeremy Brett, if he’d been a little more pugilistic when he began his run as Sherlock, would have been simply perfect.  As it is, he remains the Sherlock standard to be judged against.

IMHO.

11/24/09 • 02:58 PM • ArtsBooksEntertainmentHistory • 1 Comment

Comments:

On Brett, I agree without hesitation. Watching him play Sherlock Holmes is a joy. --Ed

Posted by Ed Bilodeau on 11/26/09 at 01:23 PM

 

Leave a comment:

name:

email:

url //:

Your email is not published.
Basic HTML is allowed. Smileys are available, if you're so inclined.

Save personal info (so you don't have to keep entering it)?

Send an email if someone else comments on this thread?

Submit the word you see below:



Previous entry: Mashable: Tips on virtual meetings.          Next entry: NY Times: Hatches still battened down?